Lumber Liquidators: Making Sense Of Insider Antics

Summary

  • Founder Tom Sullivan’s ham-fisted activism sent share price up 40% before tumbling back to pre-hype levels.
  • The possible pump-and-dump saw Sullivan increase his holdings in the company from 6% to nearly 8%, and quickly reduce to 1.55% after the stock price rose.
  • Questionable motives notwithstanding, Sullivan raised some valid criticisms regarding company costs and management, receiving support from a prominent shareholder group.
  • Lumber Liquidators is better off without Sullivan, but should heed his warnings regarding administrative bloat and endless expansion.

What a month! September was a wild ride for Lumber Liquidators (LL). What was perhaps a generic pump-and-dump by founder and former CEO, Tom Sullivan, was a windfall for savvy volatility traders. Serious stakeholders were left scratching their heads as to what exactly had occurred, and how the underlying value of the company changed.

This article seeks to get the reader up to speed on what transpired in September, what the shake-up means for the company, and why Lumber Liquidators is better off without Tom Sullivan. We will also discuss a few of Sullivan's valid critiques of the company, and how it should move forward.

What Happened

In late August, Tom Sullivan's F9 Investments increased its holdings in Lumber Liquidators by 30%, and expressed an interest in a bid to take the company private, potentially including a merger with his private company Cabinets To Go. Wall Street, clearly no fan of the firm's current situation, reacted with glee, sending shares soaring about 30% on the news.

The Lumber Liquidators Value Committee (LLVC), holding a similar 6% interest in the company, joined the chorus calling for new management and/or ownership. The group is headed by fellow Seeking Alpha contributor Mario Rizzi. Rizzi has been a vocal critic of Lumber Liquidators' current management in the past, so it comes as little surprise that the Value Committee would join Sullivan in the corporate coups.

As the stock rose on the scuttlebutt of management and ownership changes, Sullivan pulled an abrupt 180, calling the stock too expensive and deciding to offload 80% of his shares. The stock price is now around $10, near where it was before all the hubbub began.

Sullivan's Offloading Leaves Us Better Off

It is difficult to assign a clear motive to Sullivan's actions. The knee-jerk reaction is to call it a pump-and-dump, and Sullivan did make millions on the quick trade. Some, including Empire Financial's Whitney Tilson, believe that Sullivan was truly priced out of the buyout attempt as the stock price rose, and that no foul play was involved. At any rate, Sullivan has reduced his ownership to less than 2%, and should be less relevant to the company moving forward.

Tom Sullivan deserves a lot of credit for building a powerful company, and plenty of blame for the company's current dismal situation. Sullivan was at best negligent, and likely complicit, in Lumber Liquidators' illegal sourcing practices that continue to haunt the company in the form of legal costs and damage to its brand.

This recent stunt is consistent with Sullivan's apparent philosophy: personal enrichment with little regard for the long-term interest of company shareholders. If Sullivan is truly exiting the picture as an active shareholder, then good riddance.

READ FULL ARTICLE HERE